Popular Ideas
about Language Learning:
Facts and Opinions
(Summary of Lightbown
& Spada, 1993, Chapter 6)*
Important:
Remember that the statements in bold type are only popular "opinions" about
language learning, and are not necessarily completely true.The "facts,"
based on second language acquistion research, are summarized below each
of the statements.
1. Languages are
learned mainly through imitation
-
Neither L1 nor L2 is learned
mainly
through imitation.
-
Learners produce many
novel (original) utterances in addition to language they've heard before.
-
Even children learning
their first language imitate selectively.
2. Parents usually
correct young children when they make mistakes
-
Parents usually focus
on correcting meaning, not form (grammar and pronunciation).
3. People with
high IQs are good language learners
-
They may have an advantage
in memorizing grammar rules and vocabulary, but not in learning to use
language.
4. The most
important factor in second language acquisition success is motivation
-
Motivation is important,
but there are also many other factors.
-
Motivation increases success,
but success also increases motivation.
5. The earlier
a second language is introduced in school programs, the greater the likelihood
of success in learning
-
It depends on the objectives
of the program and the amount of time spent.
-
Starting earlier may lead
to more native-like acquisition eventually (especially for pronunciation),
but children who start later catch up quickly.
6. Most of the
mistakes which second language learners make are due to interference from
their first language
-
There are many causes
of error; L1 interference is just one of them.
-
Learners with different
L1s make the same errors when learning a particular L2.
7. Teachers
should present grammatical rules one at a time, and learners should practice
examples of each one before going on to another
-
Language learning is not
linear in development, but involves integrating new rules into the existing
system (i.e., "interlanguage").
-
Learners may use a rule
correctly for a while, then begin using it incorrectly, and then relearn
it.
8. Teachers
should teach simple language structures before complex ones
-
No matter how language
is presented, certain structures are acquired before others (i.e., there
is a "natural order").
-
Teachers should provide
"comprehensible input" that is understandable to learners, but also contains
some new words and structures.
9. Learners'
errors should be corrected as soon as they are made in order to prevent
the formation of bad habits
-
Errors are a natural part
of language learning.
-
Correction may only be
useful when the learner is ready for it.
-
Too much error correction
can have a negative effect on motivation, but teachers should point out
persistent errors.
10. Teachers
should use materials that expose students only to language structures which
they have already been taught
-
Learners can comprehend
the general meaning of many forms they have not learned completely.
-
Students need to be challenged;
otherwise, they may lose motivation.
-
Students have to learn
to deal with real language, not just artificial classroom language.
11. When learners
are allowed to interact freely in groups or pair activities, they learn
each others' mistakes
-
Research says that isn't
true; they don't produce more errors, and they can give useful feedback
to each other.
-
Group and pair activities
can give students more chances to produce meaningful language.
12. Students
learn what they are taught
-
While students can only
learn the language they are exposed to, they don't learn everything they
are taught, of course.
-
For learning to be successful,
the language taught must be appropriate for their level of development.
-
Students learn a lot of
language that they are not taught.
_________________
*Lightbown,
P., & Spada, N. (1993). How languages are learned. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
Class
Home Page