By Kathleen M. Bailey, Andy Curtis, and David Nunan
Boston, MA: Heinle
& Heinle, 2001,
Pp. x + 277. (ISBN
0-8384-1130-4 Paperback)
¡¡
Reviewed by Rodney
E. Tyson
The Korea TESOL Journal, 4(1), 2001.
Pursuing Professional Development is one of the latest additions to
the TeacherSource series of books edited by Donald Freeman for Heinle &
Heinle. Like the other books in the series, it is intended for pre- and
in-service language teachers. Neither the authors of this book nor the
series editor should need an introduction to most readers of this journal
since their books, articles, and workshops in the areas of language teaching
and teacher development are well-known throughout Asia and around the world.
Much of the work of all three authors has been in the area of personal
development and using personal experience as a source for pursuing professional
development: "Self-awareness and self-observation are the cornerstones
of all professional development" (p. 22). This book brings together and
adds to much of that work and details a number of techniques that teachers
can use to develop themselves as professionals.
The book begins with a short introduction that describes how the three
authors, who were all working in Hong Kong at the time, came to write the
book together. This is followed by the series editor¡¯s preface which explains
the objective of the series, which is to make the authors' "experience
and point of view" (p. viii) the central concern--to illustrate through
that personal experience and point of view rather than try to "tell" readers
what is important in the more traditional way. The first three chapters
of the book develop the authors' theoretical background for the more practical
material that makes up most of the book. In the first chapter, the authors
explore the question of why professional development is necessary. In the
second chapter, they discuss the value of self-awareness and self-observation
for teachers, and in the third, they take a close look at the many definitions
of "reflective teaching," a concept which, of course, "underpins the rest
of the book" (p. 34). Each of the next nine chapters focuses exclusively
on one method of teacher development. The titles of the chapters themselves
say much about the content: teaching journals, using cases, language learning
experience, video, action research, peer observation, team teaching, mentoring
and coaching, and teaching portfolios. The book ends with two appendices
containing a transcript of an actual lesson taught by David Nunan and the
results of a survey on team teaching conducted by Kathleen Bailey (both
of which are discussed in the text, of course) and fourteen pages of references.
One thing that sets books in the TeacherSource series apart from other
more typical books written for language teachers is their unique organization.
Each book is built around three different types of content, or "strands"
(p. ix). These three strands are meant to provide a balance of practical
insight into teaching, theoretical background, and ideas for discussion
and reflection. "Teachers' Voices" are first-person accounts, or stories
really, in which various practicing language teachers are allowed to speak
for themselves about their experiences and problems in teaching. "Frameworks"
are sections that lay out the more theoretical concepts and issues that
the authors feel are important for readers to understand in order to make
sense of the topics under discussion. "Investigations" are short activities
that encourage readers to pause and reflect on their own experiences and
ideas about language teaching. In the text, the beginning of a new strand
is indicated by a unique graphical symbol in the margin.
In Pursuing Professional Development, each chapter includes several
sections of each of the three strands, which are interwoven in various
sequences to reinforce one another. For example, in Chapter 12 on teaching
portfolios, after a very short introduction, there is a "frameworks" section
of slightly over two pages that defines portfolios and discusses why they
are important. Following that is a "teachers' voice" section of a little
less than two pages in which David Nunan writes about his personal experiences
and feelings about creating his own teaching portfolio. Next is another
longer "frameworks" section that discusses what might be included in a
portfolio. Readers are then asked to pause and reflect on what they have
read so far in the chapter. An "investigations" activity, which includes
a chart to fill in, encourages them to think or talk about what they themselves
would want to include in a teaching portfolio. The rest of the chapter
includes one more "frameworks" section, two more "teachers' voices" sections,
and two more "investigations" sections. Each chapter ends with a list of
"tasks for development" and an annotated list of very relevant suggested
readings.
I found this book an excellent overview of specific ways of "pursuing professional
development." The authors build on theory, their personal experiences,
and the experiences of other teachers in a variety of situations to cover
a number of proven techniques for personal development quite thoroughly.
More than any other book on reflective teaching I have read, this book
actually shows--through a combination of explanation, examples, and constant
challenges to the readers--how teachers can reflect on their teaching.
The authors recognize, however, that not every technique is right for every
teacher. Instead, readers are constantly invited to decide for themselves
where they stand on the issues discussed in the book. They are encouraged
through the frequent "investigations" to look inside themselves, draw on
their own experiences, and find their own way--in short, to use "the self
as source." In the concluding chapter, "The Heart of the Paradox," the
authors point out that "professional development is not something that
just happens: It must be actively pursued" (p. 246). The ideas and suggestions
in this book can help teachers to do just that.
Pursuing Professional Development should be of interest and value to
both in-service teachers and students preparing to become teachers. Thanks
to the questions and activities in the "investigations" sections scattered
throughout the book and the list of tasks at the end of each chapter which
often encourage collaboration and discussion, it might be an especially
good choice for a graduate seminar or a less formal group of practicing
teachers interested in professional development. However, the questions
and tasks can also be appreciated by a reader working through them alone,
or at least thinking through them alone, as I often found myself doing
as I read through the book. Finally, although discussion and explanation
in the book is thorough and complete, the language used is straight-forward
and simple enough that the book should be accessible to many teachers and
students who are nonnative speakers of English.
The Reviewer:
Rodney E. Tyson (Ph.D.,
University of Arizona) is an associate professor in the English Department
at the American University of Sharjah in the United Arab Emirates. Before
taking his current position, he taught at three universities in Korea for
a total of more than 12 years.
Email: rtyson@aus.ac.ae