By Marion Williams and Robert L. Burden
Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press, 1997,
Pp. ix + 240. (ISBN
0 521 49880 5 Paperback)
¡¡
Reviewed by Rodney
E. Tyson
The Korea TESOL Journal, 3(1), 2000.
I first became aware of the unique collaboration between Marion Williams,
an applied linguist, and Robert L. Burden, an educational psychologist,
when I attended their presentation on motivation in language learning at
the 12th World Congress of Applied Linguistics in Tokyo last summer (Williams
& Burden, 1999). That experience led me to buy a copy of their book,
Psychology
for Language Teachers, which I found useful not just for its insightful
chapter on motivation, but also because it is a thorough, but very accessible
overview of important issues and developments in the field of educational
psychology of particular relevance to language teachers.
In his keynote address at the same conference, Michael Long (Long, 1999)
pointed out that "all theories are at some level interim understandings
of what theorists ultimately seek to explain" but stressed the importance
of theories of second language acquisition (SLA) being judged on the basis
of their relevance for language teaching. Williams and Burden would seem
to agree when they argue that "there has never been a time when language
teaching and learning was more in need of a systematic educational underpinning
to its activities" (p. 44). They state that the main purpose of their book
is to provide that type of underpinning.
The model they choose to provide the framework is that of a social constructivist
approach, which they describe as a perspective in which "learners make
their own sense of their world, but they do so within a social context,
and through social interaction" (p. 28, italics in original). In
that sense, learners may learn in very different ways, even when provided
with very similar learning experiences, because each individual constructs
his or her own reality.
The book contains ten chapters. The first two chapters provide an introduction
to theories and developments in the field of educational psychology that
have influenced language teaching and present the basic concepts of the
authors¡¯ social constructivist approach. Four key factors are identified
which interact to influence the learning process. These include teachers,
learners, tasks, and contexts. As might be expected, the rest of the book
elaborates on these factors.
Two chapters focus on the role of teachers in the language learning process
and what they can do to promote learning. Three chapters discuss, within
the framework of the authors' social constructivist model, different aspects
of what learners bring to the language learning situation--how individual
learners "make sense" (p. 88) of their own learning situations, the "multifaceted
nature" (p. 111) of motivation in language learning, and how it is that
learners actually go about learning something. The last of these considers
the skills and strategies learners make use of as well as the processes
they go through to, again, "make sense" (p. 143) of their learning. One
chapter each is then devoted to the remaining key factors in the model,
that is, the place of tasks in the language classroom and the ways in which
the learning context, or more realistically, the "variety of often overlapping
contexts" (p. 188), affect language learning.
The final chapter provides a succinct summary of main ideas discussed throughout
the book. This summary takes the form of a list of ten propositions that
the authors consider "crucial for language teachers" (p. 204), each of
which is followed by a very short and easily understandable explanation
of the authors¡¯ views about that particular issue. In fact, this short
chapter would be worth reading in its own right, even without the rest
of the book. It would make excellent material, for example, for a discussion
of teachers' practices and beliefs in a workshop setting or a graduate
class in SLA or language teaching methodology.
In Psychology for Language Teachers, Williams and Burden summarize
a vast amount of relevant research related to language learning and teaching,
but make it accessible to the average language teacher. For readers with
teaching experience but little or no background in SLA theory and the psychology
of language learning, this is an excellent introduction that should be
both understandable and useful. For readers with more extensive knowledge
of SLA theory, the review of the psychology research fills in some of the
background information about how and why the theories developed, which
is (perhaps understandably) usually left out of other popular books written
by and for language teachers or applied linguists (e.g., Brown, 1994; Lightbown
& Spada, 1999). In that sense, it provides some reassurance to teachers
by showing that the prominent theories of SLA and methods of language teaching
did not just develop in a vacuum, but that there really is some solid psychological
research backing them up.
Most importantly, this book really is written for language teachers, although
it can be read at two different levels. For those interested in psychological
theory, there is a thorough overview of the important research and developments
in the field related to language teaching, which can be appreciated regardless
of one's particular theoretical views. For those who are simply interested
in developing their teaching ability, on the other hand, there is a wealth
of theoretically-grounded, but straight-forward advice for language teachers.
This book, then, should be useful for virtually all practicing language
teachers as well as graduate students in fields related to language teaching.
The Reviewer:
Rodney E. Tyson (Ph.D.,
University of Arizona) is an associate professor at Daejin University in
Korea, where he teaches undergraduate and graduate courses in English and
English Education and coordinates the General English Program.
References
Brown, H. D. (1994). Principles of language learning and teaching. (3rd ed.). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Lightbown, P., & Spada, N. (1999). How languages are learned. (2nd ed.). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Long, M. (1999). Theories and theory change in SLA. Keynote address at the 12th World Congress of Applied Linguistics, Tokyo.
Williams, M., & Burden, R. L. (1999). Motivation in foreign language learning: A social constructivist perspective. Paper presented at the 12th World Congress of Applied Linguistics, Tokyo.