Peer/Self Review Form #1

ESSAY ASSIGNMENT #1: Record of First Drafts Read During Class Exchange

Reader's Name ____________________
 

Rating Scale:

3 = Yes
2 = Somewhat
1 = No
                                   Something memorable              Is it             Are there          Is it well       Is it easy to
  Writer's name                 about the essay            interesting?  enough details?  organized?   understand?

1. ____________                                                         _____              _____              _____              _____
 
 

2. ____________                                                         _____              _____              _____              _____
 
 

3. ____________                                                         _____              _____              _____              _____
 
 

4. ____________                                                         _____              _____              _____              _____
 
 

5. ____________                                                         _____              _____              _____              _____
 
 

6. ____________                                                         _____              _____              _____              _____
 
 


 
 

SELF-EVALUATION: ESSAY #1

1. The most outstanding essay I read today was written by ____________. I liked it for this (these) reason(s):
 
 
 
 
 

2. Now, read your own essay again and answer the following questions honestly:

Is it interesting? _____

Are there enough details? _____

Is it well organized? _____

Is it easy to understand? _____

What is (are) the greatest strength(s) of your essay so far?
 
 
 

What is (are) the greatest weakness(es) of your essay so far?
 
 
 

What do you plan to do to improve your essay when you write the second draft?
 
 
 

Form #1 | Form #2 | Form #3 | Return to Handout